Plastic Waste Regime in Rwanda, Kenya and South Africa: A Comparative Case Study

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47672/ajl.1652

Keywords:

Plastic waste, Legal Framework, Single-use plastics, Plastic ban

Abstract

Purpose: Plastic waste has become a major environmental concern worldwide, posing significant challenges to ecosystems, human health, and sustainable development. This case study explores the plastic waste regimes in three African countries: Rwanda, Kenya and South Africa. By examining these countries' policies, strategies, and initiatives, the study aims to highlight their approaches to managing plastic waste and draw lessons for effective waste management practices.

Methodology: The case study utilises a comparative analysis framework to identify similarities and differences in the plastic waste regimes of the three countries. It examines the regulatory frameworks, waste management infrastructure, public awareness campaigns, and recycling initiatives implemented in each country.Furthermore, the study delves into plastic waste's socio-economic and environmental impacts and evaluates the effectiveness of the measures taken to address the issue.

Findings: Findings demonstrate that Kenya, Rwanda, and South Africa have adopted diverse strategies to tackle plastic waste. Rwanda has established a comprehensive waste management system emphasising recycling and community engagement, while Kenya has implemented a ban on plastic bags. South Africa, on the other hand, has embraced extended producer responsibility and developed a recycling infrastructure. These strategies have led to varying degrees of success in reducing plastic waste and promoting sustainable practices. An examination of the challenges faced by each country revealed factors such as inadequate waste infrastructure, limited resources, and the need for behavioural change among citizens. It also identified the role of stakeholders, including government agencies, non-governmental organizations, and the private sector, in driving plastic waste management initiatives.

Recommendations: Finally, relying on the substantive legitimacy theory, the study provides recommendations based on the acceptability of the policies and best practices observed in the case countries. These include investment in waste management infrastructure, public education and awareness campaigns, and stakeholder collaboration. Countries can effectively address the plastic waste challenge by adopting an integrated approach that combines policy interventions, infrastructure development, and behavioural change. Overall, this case study contributes to the understanding of plastic waste management in Rwanda, Kenya and South Africa, shedding light on successful strategies and areas for improvement. It emphasises the importance of a holistic and collaborative approach to create sustainable plastic waste regimes that protect the environment, promote circular economy principles, and safeguard public health.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Caliendo H, "˜The Economic Effect of Plastic Bag Bans', available at https://www.plasticstoday.com/business/economic-effect-plastic-bag-bans (accessed 4 April 2021).

Kohls R "˜The Plastic Bag Debate: Lessons from Rwanda' The Dominion June 2011 10, https://www.torontoenvironment.org/newsroom/teainthenews/other20110610 (accessed 23 May 2021).

Lindblom C Politics and Markets: The World's Political-economic Systems. (1977) Basic Books New York

Xie J & Martin J "˜Plastic Waste Management in Rwanda: An Ex-Post Policy Analysis' available at https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstream/handle/10986/37607/P1791430174c860e0a9af0cb4b442deb33.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y (accessed 13 October 2022).

Chapter in Books

Van der Doelen CJF "˜The "Give-and-Take" Packaging of Policy Instruments: Optimizing Legitimacy and Effectiveness' in Bemelmans-Videc, Rist, & Vedung (eds.) Carrots, Sticks and Sermons - Policy Instruments and Their Evaluation. (2011) 129-135.

Vedung E 'Policy Instruments: Typologies and Theories' in Bemelmans- Videc, Rist, & Vedung (eds.) Carrots, Sticks and Sermons - Policy Instruments and Their Evaluation (2011) Transaction Publishers New Jersey

Bulletins

Caliendo H, "˜The Economic Effect of Plastic Bag Bans', (February 6, 2013) available at https://www.plasticstoday.com/business/economic-effect-plastic-bag-bans

CIPRO "˜Tackle the Landfill Crisis' available at https://www.plasticrecyclingsa.co.za/ (accessed 17 June 2020).

The Economist "˜Kenya tries to ban plastic bags - again '(Mar 23 2017) available at https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2017/03/23/kenya-tries-to-ban-plastic-bags-again

Tikologo, Izindaba & Omngewingsnuus "˜Minister drives thuma mina call for a cleaner SA' available at https://www.dffe.gov.za/sites/default/files/docs/publications/environnews_sowetansupplementJune2018.pdf

Kairu P "˜Will we triumph in the war on plastics?' available at .https://nation,africa/kenya/life-and-style/dn2/will-we- triumph-in-the-war-on-plastics"”451908

Kirsten E, "˜Africa leads world in plastic bag ban' (2019) available at https://getaway.co.za. (accessed 17 November 2022)

Kenya Plastic Action Plan "˜Accelerating a Circular Economy in Kenya' available at https://kam.co.ke/kam/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/KPAP_Document-pages.pdf (accessed 14 November 2022).

Knowler W "˜Why prices are rising' available at http://ww.iol.co.za/general/other/lol_container.php (accessed 25 September 2008).

Mahajan R "˜Plastics Ban: Finding Alternatives' (2020) available at https://www.dandc.eu/en/article/rwanda-taking-its-ban-single-use-plastic-bags-one-big-step-further-include-most-other-types

Radhia Mtonga, "˜Commentary: Rwanda offers a plastic recycling model worth emulating' Recycling today, October 11, 2022, https://www.recyclingtoday.com/article/rwanda-plastic-recycling-circular-economy-radhia-mtonga/

Scientific Action and Advocacy Network "˜' Effectiveness of plastic regulation around the world' available at https://plasticpollutioncoalitionresources.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/Effectiveness_of_plastic_regulation_around_the_world_4_pages.pdf (accessed 20 November 2022).

Cases

Kenya Association of Manufacturers & 2 Others vs Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources and 3Others (2017) 32 (ELC)

Journals

Block F "˜The ruling class does not rule' (1977) Socialist Revolution.

Behuria P "˜Ban the (Plastic) bag? Explaining variation in the implementation of Plastic bag ban in Rwanda, Kenya and Uganda' (2021) 39(8), SAGE Journals Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space.

Carr TR 'Public administrators and policy legitimization: Policy analysis, politics and power' (1993) 16(8) International Journal of Public Administration,

Chasse C, Evaluation of Legal Strategies for the Reduction of Plastic Bag Consumption (Master thesis, Harvard Extension School, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2018).

Clapp J & Swanston L "˜Doing away with plastic shopping bags: International patterns of norm emergence and policy implementation' (2009) 18 (3) Environmental Politics.

Dikgang, Leiman & Visser "˜Analysis of the plastic bag levy in South Africa' (2012) 66 Resour. Conserv. Recycle

Eskeland GS and Jimenez E 'Policy instruments for pollution control in developing countries' (1992) 7 (2) The World Bank Research Observer

Hanekom A "˜South African initiative to end plastic pollution in the environment' (2020) 116(5/6) S Afr J Sci.

Kaza, Yao, Perinaz et al What a Waste 2.0: A Global Snapshot of Solid Waste Management to 2050. (2018)

Lange, Inganga, Busienei et al "˜The prevalence of plastic bag waste in the rumen of slaughtered livestock at three abattoirs in Nairobi Metropolis, Kenya and implications on livestock health' (2018) Livestock Research for Rural Development 30(11) Article #182.

Mangizvo RV "˜The incidence of plastic waste and their effects in Alice, South Africa' (2012) 1, (2) Online Journal of Social Sciences 49-53

Mazhandu, Muzenda, Mamvura et al "˜Integrated and consolidated review of plastic waste management and bio-based biodegradable plastics: challenges and opportunities' (2020) 12(20) Sustainability 8360,

Mazhandu, Muzenda, Belaid et al "˜A review of plastic waste management practices: what can South Africa learn' (2021) 6(2) Advances in Science, Technology and Engineering Systems Journal (ASTESJ) 1013-1028.

Meelis T (2002). Plastic bags: Do we need them? Labour News, 11(1), Johannesburg: COSATU.

Miliband R The State in Capitalist Society (1973) Quartet London.

Nhamo G "˜Social marketing: Can it enhance reuse and recycling at the household level in the SADC region?' at the EEASA 21st International Conference Windhoek Namibia (2003a).

Muzenda, Mamvura et al "˜Integrated and consolidated review of plastic waste management and bio-based biodegradable plastics: challenges and opportunities' (2020) 12(20) Sustainability 8360, doi:10.3390/su12208360.

Ngobese Z "˜Degradable plastic bags go on sale in July' available at http://www.busrep.co.za/ (accessed 17 November 2022).

Nhamo G "˜Waste Management Policy implementation in South Africa: An emerging stakeholder participation paradox' (2003) 20 Southern African Journal of Environmental Education.

Njeru J "˜The urban political ecology of plastic bag waste problem in Nairobi, Kenya', (2006) 37 6 Geoforum

Nwafor & Walker "˜Plastic bags prohibition bill: a developing story of crass legalism aiming to reduce plastic marine pollution in Nigeria' (2020) 120 Marine Policy.

Taiwo, Otieno &Venter "˜Towards attaining the Polokwane waste reduction goals - where are we?' (2008) 53 Town and Regional Planning 25-31 doi:10.10520/EJC108684.

Pritish B "˜Ban the (plastic) bag? Explaining variation in the implementation of plastic bag bans in Rwanda, Kenya and Uganda' (2021) 39 (8) SAGE Journals Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space.

Sharp, Høj, & Wheeler 'Proscription and its impact on anti-consumption behavior and attitudes: the case of plastic bags' (2010) 9 Journal of Consumer Behavior.

Legislation

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa of 1996.

Environmental Conservation Act Management of 1989; National Environmental Management Act of 1998;

Environmental Conservation Act of 1989.

Environmental Management and Coordination Act of 2017 (EMC A Cap 387) Gazette notice No. 2334, of 28 February 2017.

Environmental Management and Coordination Act No 8 of 1999. Revised 2016 (2014)

Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act, No. 8 of 1999, § 144 (Jan. 14, 2000

Environmental Management and Co-ordination Act, No. 8 of 1999, § 144 (Jan. 14, 2000), Kenya.

Environmental Conservation Act (Act No.73

Gazette notice No. 2334, of 28 February 2017,

Law No 53/2007 of 17/11/2007 establishing community works in Rwanda (Umuganda).

Law N° 09/2013 of 01/03/2013 establishing the Rwanda Utilities Regulatory Authority (RURA)

Law No. 17/2019, GN 37 of 23 September 2019. Law Relating to the Prohibition of Manufacturing, Importation, Use and Sale of Plastic Carry Bags and Single-Use Plastic Items Rwanda,

National Environmental Management: Waste Act No 59 of 2008 NEM: WA.

National Environmental Management Act No. 107 of 1998.

National Environmental Management Waste Amendment Act of 2014,

National Environmental Management Act No. 107 ,1998. South Africa.

Organic Law No.04/2005 determines the modalities of Protection, Conservation, and Promotion of the Environment in Rwanda.

Plastic Bag Control and Management Regulations of 2018.

Plastic Carrier Bags and Plastic Flat Bag Regulations of 2003.

Polokwane Declaration on Waste Management of September 2001,

Prohibition of Manufacturing, Importation, Use and Sale of Polythene bags in Rwanda, Law No 57/2008 of 10 September 2008.

Republic of South Africa Environment Conservation Act 73 of 1989.

Wildlife Conservation and Management Act 2013, Act no.24 of 1953, CAP .204-

Regulations, Policies and Guidelines and Action Plans

Amendment and Regulations and Notices Regarding Extended Producer Responsibility of 2020 (EPR).

Extended Producer Responsibility Regulation 2020.

Guidelines on Procedures on eligibility to grant exceptional permission to manufacture, use, import, or sell single-use plastic Items or pack goods in Single-Use Plastics

Kenya's Draft Extended Producer Responsibility Regulations. (2020)

Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Implementation Plan for The Ban of Single-Use Plastics in Protected Areas, February 2020.

Ministry of Environment "˜The implementation plan for the ban of single-use plastics' available at https://www.tourism.go.ke/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/Action-Plan-Single-Use-Plastics-Ban-in-Protected-Areas-February2020.pdf

Ministry of Environment and Forestry "˜Plastic Action Plan: Implementation plan for the Ban of Single-use Plastics in Protected Areas' Pg 5, February 2020

National Sustainable Waste Management Policy Ministry of Environment and Forestry; (Sessional Paper No. X of 2018.

Ministerial Order N° 005/2008 of 15/08/2008. Establishing modalities of inspecting companies or activities that pollute the environment, Government of Rwanda (2008).

National Sustainable Waste Management Policy Ministry of Environment and Forestry; (Sessional Paper No. X of 2018

National Domestic Waste Collection Standards of 201.

National Policy for the Provision of Basic Refuse Removal Services to Indigent Households of 2011

Norms and Standards for the Disposal of waste to landfill of 2013.

National Waste Management Strategy, 2011. Department of Environmental Affairs, 2011 (DEA).

Regulations regarding the control of the Import or Export of Waste, 2019,

Regulations Governing Solid Waste and Transportation Services of 2020,

Regulation No 001/EWASTAN/SW/RURA/2014 of 28/8/2014 on solid waste collection and transportation services provision in Rwanda and all other previous provisions.

Repeal of Regulations No. R543 published in GG No. 23393 dated 9 May 200

Waste Classification and Management Regulation of 2013

Reports

Behuria P "˜The comparative political economy of plastic bag bans in East Africa: why implementation has varied in Rwanda, Kenya and Uganda' 2019 (037) GDI Working Paper.

Human Rights Watch Justice Compromised: The Legacy of Rwanda's Community-Based Gacaca Courts. (2011) HRW Rep

Ministry of Environment "˜The implementation plan for the ban of single-use plastics 2020

Mtonga R "˜Commentary: Rwanda offers a plastic recycling model worth emulating' available at https://www.recyclingtoday.com/article/rwanda-plastic-recycling-circular-economy-radhia-mtonga (accessed 11 October 2022).

National Sustainable Waste Management Policy Ministry of Environment and Forestry; (Sessional Paper No. X of 2018.

Rajashekar, Bowers & Gatoni "˜Assessing Waste Management services in Kigali' (2019) Final Report, International Growth Centre (C-38435-RWA-1)

UNEP "˜Kenya announces breakthrough ban on plastic bags. (2017)

United Nations Environment Programme Report 2005 Selection, Design and Implementation of Economic Instruments in the Solid Waste Management Sector in Kenya: The Case of Plastic Bags' (2005).

United Nations Environment Programme Single Use Plastics Report 2018- Single Use Plastics: A Roadmap for Sustainability (2018)

Weigand F, Investigating the Role of Legitimacy in the Political Order of Conflict-torn Spaces, (2015) Working Paper, Security in Transition: An Interdisciplinary Investigation into the Security Gap.

World Bank Report (2019) "˜Plastic Waste Management in Rwanda: An Ex-Post Policy Analysis.

Mtonga R "˜Commentary: Rwanda offers a plastic recycling model worth emulating' available at https://www.recyclingtoday.com/article/rwanda-plastic-recycling-circular-economy-radhia-mtonga (accessed 11 October 2022).

Thesis and Research Proposal

Danielsson M The Plastic Bag Ban in Rwanda: Local Procedures and Successful Outcomes - A Case Study on how Rwanda Implemented a Nation-wide Ban on Plastic Bags, (unpublished, master's thesis, Uppsala University, Sweden, 2017).

Miller RM 'Plastic shopping bags: An Analysis of Policy Instruments for Plastic Bag Reduction' (Unpublished MSc thesis, Universitei Utrecht 2012) 33, 36.

Nhamo G Plastic bags: Regulations, Compliance, Tensions and Responses (Unpublished research proposal and poster, Rhodes University, Grahamstown. (2003b).

Newspaper

Barret A "˜Did the Kenya Plastic Bag Ban Work?' available at https://bioplasticsnews.com/2020/03/04/plastic-bag-ban-kenya/ (accessed 10 July 10, 2022)

BBC News Reality Check team "˜Has Kenya's plastic bag ban worked' (28 August 2019) available at https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-49421885 (accessed 14, November 2022).

Clavel & Émilie, "˜Think you can't live without plastic bags? consider this: Rwanda did it available at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/feb/15/rwanda-banned-plastic-bags-so-can-we (accessed 14 May 2021).

Dsilva E, Going surgical on plastics in Rwanda' Down To Earth 24 December 2019

https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/waste/going-surgical-on-plastics-in-Rwanda-68446 (accessed 25

October 2022).

Independent "˜Kenya Bans Plastic Bags' available at https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/kenya-bans-plastic-bags-2179928.html (accessed 12 November 2022).

Martinko K "˜Kenyans adjust to life without plastic bags' available at https://amp-theguardian-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/amp (accessed 14 November 2022

McCune R, "˜Purging Plastics' available at http://www.hotelnewsnow.com/Articles/288882/How-hotel-companies-resorts-are-banning-plastic (accessed 15 November 2022)

Musoke R "˜Polythene bags: the menace of East Africa' The Independent (April 23, 2017) available at https://www.independent.co.ug.polythene-bags-menace-east-africa/ (accessed 13 October 2022)

National Environment Management Authority "˜2 years on: Say no to plastic bags' available at https://www.nema.go.ke/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=296&-catid=2&Itemid=451 (accessed 12 July 2022).

Ocean Wise "˜Rwanda's Plastic-Bag Black Market', New York Times 7 December 2017 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/28/world/africa/rwanda-plastic-bags-banned.html (accessed 13 May 2021).

Pilgrim & Sophie "˜Smugglers work on the dark side of Rwanda's plastic bag ban'. available at http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2016/2/25/rwanda-plastic-bag-ban.html (accessed 31 May 2020).

Watts J Eight months on, is the world's most drastic plastic bag ban working? The Guardian, 25 April.2018

Downloads

Published

2023-11-15

How to Cite

Uche, O. L. . (2023). Plastic Waste Regime in Rwanda, Kenya and South Africa: A Comparative Case Study. American Journal of Law, 5(2), 54–85. https://doi.org/10.47672/ajl.1652